Sweet Tomatoes ~ Shelter Island, NY ~~ Love this restaurant!
Iron Pier Beach ~ Jamesport, NY
Kenny's Beach ~ Southold, NY
Lavender by the Bay ~ East Marion, NY
Grana ~ Jamesport, NY ~~This place has awesome wood fired pizza. I recommend reservations as this place is small and can get very busy. My favorite pizza is called the Grana.
1943 Pizza Bar ~ Greenport, NY ~~ Another fave for one of a kind pizza!